« Georgia case: lessor of land from city (in state with pre-emption) cannot ban firearms | Main | One way of solving a problem »
New California gun laws
Fox News is reporting. I don't have time to look up the laws themselves, but this report of them raises big constitutional questions (other than the obvious 2A and due process ones). Does the law make failure to turn over firearms a criminal offense? If not, where is the probable cause for a search? "Probable cause" assumes a crime. The provision that a warrant may be issued with the order, to become effective if the gun owner refuses to turn over a gun, raises questions of anticipatory search warrants. Those were a big issue some years ago, I forget how it turned out, but they weren't in favor with the courts. The idea was to issue a search warrant over a future event, to become effective (without further restore to a court) if something happened. E.g., here is the evidence we have of drug dealing (not quite probable cause). We're going to send in an informant. This warrant to immediately search the house will become effective only if the informant comes out and reports he made a drug buy inside.
2 Comments | Leave a comment
By the time the ACLU says a gun law is a bad idea you know you are doing something wrong.
I wish folks could read English and follow the grammar. The 4th Amendment DOES NOT allow a search based on probable cause. Probable cause is required to obtain a warrant and a warrant is REQUIRED to conduct a search, ANY search. And the 4th applies wholly to ALL levels of government regardless of s2pid judges.
Basic education about the grammar and punctuation of the 4th tells us that the first and second clauses are DEPENDENT not independent because they are separated by a comma, not a semicolon or period. It is sad that the judiciary is so poorly educated. What is sadder is that the judiciary decided in 1833 that the 4th didn't apply to the states thus opening a door for violations of the People's Rights.
Maybe, just maybe someday folks will learn the language, the law, and then authority of the People over the government.