Of Arms and the Law

Navigation
About Me
Contact Me
Archives
XML Feed
Home


Law Review Articles
Firearm Owner's Protection Act
Armed Citizens, Citizen Armies
2nd Amendment & Historiography
The Lecture Notes of St. George Tucker
Original Popular Understanding of the 14th Amendment
Originalism and its Tools


2nd Amendment Discussions

1982 Senate Judiciary Comm. Report
2004 Dept of Justice Report
US v. Emerson (5th Cir. 2001)

Click here to join the NRA (or renew your membership) online! Special discount: annual membership $25 (reg. $35) for a great magazine and benefits.

Recommended Websites
Ammo.com, deals on ammunition
Scopesfield: rifle scope guide
Ohioans for Concealed Carry
Clean Up ATF (heartburn for headquarters)
Concealed Carry Today
Knives Infinity, blades of all types
Buckeye Firearms Association
NFA Owners' Association
Leatherman Multi-tools And Knives
The Nuge Board
Dave Kopel
Steve Halbrook
Gunblog community
Dave Hardy
Bardwell's NFA Page
2nd Amendment Documentary
Clayton Cramer
Constitutional Classics
Law Reviews
NRA news online
Sporting Outdoors blog
Blogroll
Instapundit
Upland Feathers
Instapunk
Volokh Conspiracy
Alphecca
Gun Rights
Gun Trust Lawyer NFA blog
The Big Bore Chronicles
Good for the Country
Knife Rights.org
Geeks with Guns
Hugh Hewitt
How Appealing
Moorewatch
Moorelies
The Price of Liberty
Search
Email Subscription
Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

 

Credits
Powered by Movable Type 6.8.7
Site Design by Sekimori

« Makes me glad Trump fired his arse... | Main | 8th anniversary of McDonald v. Chicago »

Justice Kennedy just announced his retirement

Posted by David Hardy · 27 June 2018 01:03 PM

Very interesting. There has been debate, since McDonald, as to whether other members of the Court were unsure of his willingness to go beyond the basic Heller right, and whether that why why the Court was turning down otherwise quite impressive petitions for cert. Maybe so, but I've always wondered if it was a different vote that they were unsure of. Kennedy had, after all, volunteered for a heavy weapons platoon assignment in the Army, and had taught a seminar class on the 2A long, long before Heller.

Prepare for a bruising battle on this nomination. The last one didn't change the balance of power any, a conservative replacement for a conservative. This one will change it some. Kennedy usually voted with the conservative wing, but shifted to the liberal one on some issues (most notably things to do with gay rights), so for people who see those issues as important, his replacement by a person who consistently goes with the conservative wing will be a complete and dramatic change in the Court's composition. I suspect those issues will predominate, not the new nominee's 2A stance.

But for that stance, give us Hardiman of the Third Circuit, who strongly dissented from a ruling upholding NJ's permit law, and suggested that "shall issue" permitting and/or legal open carry were necessary to pass constitutional muster.

9 Comments | Leave a comment

Bill Twist | June 27, 2018 1:37 PM | Reply

I've been of the mind that both sides were gun-shy because of Kennedy.

Either side, sans Kennedy, had the 4 justices needed to grant cert, but I think that neither side was confident where he would come down on things like assault weapons or concealed carry. Both sides would have been worried about "loosing all the marbles", with the pro-gun justices worried that if he flips, the Second Amendment gets watered down to nothing, and the anti-gun justices worried that if he votes with the pro-gun justices, a lot of existing laws in states like New York, New Jersey, and California will have to be struck down.

Hopefully this will break that deadlock, with a solid pro-Second Amendment justice.

Ian Argent | June 27, 2018 2:05 PM | Reply

Kennedy almost certainly never voted for cert after McDonald.

AntiCitizenOne | June 27, 2018 8:42 PM | Reply

I'm not sure where I heard it from, but I was told Scalia had to write the Heller decision with "reasonable restrictions" in order to get Kennedy on board.

"Both sides would have been worried about "loosing all the marbles", with the pro-gun justices worried that if he flips, the Second Amendment gets watered down to nothing."

We've been wondering if Roberts is truly pro-gun since his rulings on the Affordable Care Act. Kennedy may not be our only problem.

Fyooz | June 27, 2018 9:56 PM | Reply

"wondering if Roberts is truly pro-gun since his rulings on the Affordable Care Act"

I think the ACA rulings were, say, compelled by compromising material collected by Deep State.

Mike Murray | June 28, 2018 8:42 AM | Reply

I look forward to the day when Ruth Bader Ginsburg leaves. Retirement is unlikely. She will probably go only when carried feet first from the building.

AntiCitizenOne | June 28, 2018 8:12 PM | Reply

"compelled by compromising material collected by Deep State. "

Which would be...?

Bill Twist replied to comment from AntiCitizenOne | June 29, 2018 9:29 AM | Reply

.... a conspiracy theory.

kukuforguns | June 29, 2018 1:35 PM | Reply

I've vacillated between Roberts and Kennedy as the reason for the boycott on 2d A cases. We'll know if it was Kennedy in 12 months.

chris | July 2, 2018 6:02 PM | Reply

Maybe it was both Roberts and Kennedy.

Leave a comment