« Nationwide concealed carry for LEOS | Main | Non-gun killer »
Ed Sutor on medical costs of gunshot injuries
Some years ago the antis (led in part by the Joyce Fdn) created the approach of treating GSW as a medical issue, which had some PR benefits to their cause. Dr. Edgar Sutor, chair of Doctors for Integrity in Public Research, has taken the lead in responding.
Here is his response to an article along these lines, published in the Amer. J. of Preventative Medicine. He points out:
1. The article claims that millions are spent treating gunshot wounds ... but the sums mentioned are only 0.064% of America's total medical costs.
2. This is a 60% decline since the last such study (1993) despite millions of new firearms entering the market annually.
3. No one would attempt a cost-benefit analysis without considering benefits (here, lives saved by defensive uses). Estimates are that medical negligence kills about 180,000 Americans annually, after all, but this hardly proves that medicine is useless or doctors should be avoided, since presumably many times that number are saved.
Some others of Dr. Ed's writings:
Guns In the Medical Literature: A Failure of Peer Review. An excellent and detailed article.
Violence in America, from the J. of Medical Assn't of Georgia.
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://armsandthelaw.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/83